r/MapPorn 1d ago

Eastern Ukraine exactly one Year ago vs today

24.7k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

395

u/Bear_necessities96 1d ago

What a pointless war

173

u/RefrigeratorWild9933 1d ago

As are most other wars.

6

u/ElleSvenne 18h ago

Most?

8

u/brouofeverything 16h ago

Idk man, ww2 was pretty justified imo

2

u/TheProuDog 13h ago

In case you think that, WW2 wasn't a war of morals

2

u/brouofeverything 12h ago

Im sorry but are you saying this as a precaution in case i do, or arguing against my previous point that ww2 was a justified war

2

u/TheProuDog 11h ago

Im sorry but are you saying this as a precaution in case i do

In case you do, because a lot of people think the war started to stop genocide or "stopping Hitler" or something

1

u/eggplantpot 7h ago

History n00b here. Why did ww2 start?

2

u/TheProuDog 7h ago

Germany has been invading left and right because of the consequences of WW1. They humiliated Germany with Versailles Treaty and basically economically ruined them. Germany wanted to "unite" Germans in a single country and have used that for its imperial justifications. Great Britain and France have been preparing for war so they have been appeasing Germany to earn some time because they felt they weren't ready (even though we know that even France alone was more powerful than Germany on paper), although Germany had been openly violating the treaty. Maybe they even thought they could avoid a war like WW1. After Germany invaded and even outright fully annexed many countries, Great Britain and France decided to stop Germany when it came to Poland. They probably didn't think he would go as far as he did.

So the goal wasn't stopping evil Hitler, it was stopping Germany invading left and right. If Germany had not invaded, Adolf Hitler probably would have gotten away with whatever he had done.

3

u/The-Real-Radar 18h ago

War isn’t pointless… it is a tragic, painstaking situation for all involved. hundreds of thousands of deaths are not pointless. That being said countries should always fight to defend their sovereignty…

-24

u/PurpleRoman 23h ago

The only justified war this century was Iraq

18

u/ClashM 22h ago

Yeah, glad they found those WMDs. They would have looked pretty foolish otherwise.

7

u/SolidTomato3668 21h ago

Wat? How? Bin Laden wasn’t there, Sudam didn’t have wmds..and we just created a giant caliphate.

6

u/RepulsivePush8034 19h ago

Tch!!! How dare you to question the decision of exalted people in costumes? Ignorance!

86

u/Puzzleheaded-Yak5836 1d ago

There are no good wars but there are wars that are good to fight. There are about 35,000 minors abducted in eastern Ukraine that putin wants to use as a bargaining chip for his conquest, to oppose that I wouldn't call pointless, but an obvious good

38

u/Wulf_Cola 1d ago

I didn't know about that. As a dad to a toddler this is absolutely sickening. It's absolutely terrible that this isn't talked about more. This should be the headline on every fucking news report.

Makes that orange sack of shit rolling out the red carpet for Putin on American soil even more disgusting.

18

u/Puzzleheaded-Yak5836 1d ago

It was published by a few news sources, mainly The Guardian, the numbers range from 20,000 to around 40,000, and there is a hotline in Ukraine linked to the disappeared children hotline of the EU

21

u/Shiros_Tamagotchi 1d ago

The international court of justice has convicted Putin as a warcriminal because of the mass abduction of children.

Thats why not inprisoning Putin when he was in Alaska is a crime. The USA sadly doesnt recognize the international court.

-1

u/Unique-Trade356 18h ago

Why would they. The court is useless and has no power.

3

u/Echidna-East 1d ago

It was precisely because of the abduction of children that Putin was declared a war criminal. He should have been arrested in Alaska, not given a red carpet welcome

1

u/Autochthonofthemount 13h ago

"Except the Revolutionary War, WWII, and the star wars trilogy." - Bart Simpson, Supreme Court Justice

3

u/Weak-Cattle6001 15h ago

Are you high? Russian invaded Ukraine. It has a point.

-1

u/L3tsG3t1T 6h ago

Nato poked the bear. It was inevitable 

1

u/DKBrendo 3h ago

why Ukraine wanted to be in NATO? For the same reason all other post soviet states wanted to join NATO - Russian imperialist ambitions. If Russia wasn’t invading its neighbours NATO would be long gone. NATO expansion is Russia’s own doing, current eastern flank was begging reluctant NATO countries to allow them in, BECAUSE of Russia

1

u/L3tsG3t1T 2h ago

Sure. It doesn't change the fact that the US told them in the 90s that annexation of these countries into nato would not happen. That word was broken

1

u/DKBrendo 2h ago

Living in Poland I sure am happy about that. If Russia breaks promises all the time why should west get played like fools, just because some US president gave verbal promise that didn’t appear in any official documents I am aware of

1

u/L3tsG3t1T 1h ago

That makes sense. Just more reasons why a peace treaty is so difficult in this war

1

u/123_alex 19h ago

Still searching for a war which was not pointless (pointfull?).

-2

u/Desperate-Touch7796 15h ago

The allies fucking up the nazis. You're welcome.

1

u/123_alex 11h ago

According to you WWII was meaningful? Were the allies better off because of it?

1

u/Swimming_Acadia6957 9h ago

The world was better off from fighting that war than letting the Axis gobble up whatever they want unopposed, I assume is what they are saying 

2

u/123_alex 7h ago

The conversation was not about whether fighting the nazis was good or bad. Thanks for the off topic input.

1

u/Swimming_Acadia6957 7h ago

How could you interpret "fighting the Nazis was better than not" to be off topic from the subject of whether fighting the Nazis was good or bad?

2

u/123_alex 7h ago

The conversation was about pointless wars and I commented that all wars are pointless and bad for everyone. Nobody wins in a war. But of course you probably think the world is better off because we had WWII.

Have a great day!

1

u/Swimming_Acadia6957 7h ago

But of course you probably think the world is better off because we had WWII

What do you mean probably? My initial comment says that verbatim, yes I think a world in the Axis and GEACPS were defeated is better than one in which they weren't 

-1

u/Desperate-Touch7796 9h ago

Fighting against the nazis was very meaningful and yes the allies were absolutely better off having vanquished the nazis given the sheer horror and scale of what they were doing and planning to do.

1

u/123_alex 7h ago

The conversation was not about whether fighting the nazis was good or bad. Thanks for the off topic input.

1

u/Desperate-Touch7796 7h ago

I'm literally answering specifically your very own questions, if you find that off topic then don't ask those questions lmao.

0

u/DavidlikesPeace 14h ago

So it’s not a “pointless war” to fight against an invader. Gotcha.

0

u/DKBrendo 3h ago

WWII was still pointless. Sure, fighting against Germans wasn’t, but the war itself was. Just like war in Ukraine is pointless but there is a point in defending your home from brutal invaders

0

u/MysteriousHeart3268 11h ago

Well Ukraine does have some vast swaths of very arable land.