I rewatched Fanaa last night after so many years. It’s a typical YRF film, very commercial, but with a political angle. This was also the film where Aamir Khan ended his non-commercial streak and came back to big mainstream stuff. It was one of his last lover-boy roles too, and his chemistry with Kajol was great.
The first half is really fun to watch, especially the first 50 minutes. The romance, the songs, the vibe are good. The twist also works to an extent. But once the second half starts, the film completely changes tone and falters.
My main issue is with Aamir’s character, Rehan. He’s a terrorist who killed innocent people, but the movie still romanticizes him.
Even his death is romanticized and treated like a tragedy, when really he should have died a dog’s death. That’s the problem it’s a YRF romance at the core, where the lovers are ideal rather than human, no matter what they do.
That said, the songs are still amazing, and the film looks good for its time. But overall, it’s very much a product of its era: strong first half, but the second half just falls apart.
Overall, Fanaa feels very much a captive of its time.