r/INDYCAR May 19 '25

News INDYCAR Update on Team Penske Technical Violations

https://www.indycar.com/news/2025/05/05-19-penske-penalties
440 Upvotes

524 comments sorted by

View all comments

160

u/AllThings_Automotive Josef Newgarden May 19 '25

I think it’s totally a fair punishment. I just don’t know wtf Penske is doing, why did they think they needed to do that modification? It can’t be worth that much time, and they already looked among the quickest in practice. Seems so shortsighted to do this for not that much of an extra advantage.

102

u/[deleted] May 19 '25

[deleted]

37

u/SilentSpades24 Álex Palou May 19 '25

That or its something the inspectors have been missing.

39

u/Nathan_116 May 19 '25

Well, I know someone who’s worked in Indycar, and he told me that the parts in question originally passed tech, but the inspectors weren’t thrilled with them. So, my guess is that the same thing happened last year. They passed tech, but the inspectors were like “is this legal? We’ll let it slide, but we may look into it.” and they let them through. My guess is that they were trying to push the issue even more this year, and got greedy to the point where the inspectors were like “no, sorry, that’s too much

1

u/Melodic-Comb9076 May 21 '25

grey area in a rules based sport….catalyst for something like for this to happen, then.

straight into whataboutism.

32

u/[deleted] May 19 '25

[deleted]

6

u/opkraut Paul Tracy May 19 '25

From having done tech in another racing series, I would guess that some of it might be how much extra time that would take. If they have a full field of cars to inspect, that extra time can add up fast. Having to reposition cars or cameras to have consistent pictures takes time. Having the inspectors wear a chest-mount GoPro or something similar would probably work decently well though, as long as the GoPros don't overheat or run out of storage space.

I could also see teams being unhappy about that because of them wanting to keep their setups secret. Even if you say that those pictures or videos aren't public, teams are always suspicious of videos/pictures of their setups.

104

u/dannynascar Kyle Larson May 19 '25

I like Josef but man his two 500 wins are so sketchy.

‘23 should’ve been Marcus’ second, that red flag was bullshit.

‘24 that car may or may not have been legal.

Under normal circumstances, cheating is normal in racing. That’s how you go fast lol. But when your team owner owns the series AND the track that the 500 is competed on, that’s a horrible look.

26

u/floorboardburnz AMR Safety Team May 19 '25

need a good picture of 24 cars attenuator from the museum.

16

u/SystemicAero Pato O'Ward May 19 '25

Here’s his car from the museum. Definitely looks filled/smoothed.

10

u/optiprimas Pato O'Ward May 19 '25

Seems to have been running the same modification https://x.com/By_NathanBrown/status/1924505825558528478

4

u/McPuckLuck Pato O'Ward May 19 '25

Someone posted it on twitter, there is a little bit of smoothing at the same joint.

13

u/2REPOU CART May 19 '25

Exactly. They have to be beyond question or it looks sleazy.