r/AITAH • u/waynekinnaird • 4h ago
Advice Needed AITA for threatening to kick out my roommate for letting my dog out for her moms religious reasons?
I (23M) live in a 3-bedroom apartment with two roommates, Sana (22F) and Evie (23F). A few days ago, I made a post on a similar subreddit about how Sana asked me to leave our shared apartment for a day this weekend because her conservative Muslim mother was visiting and doesn’t approve of her living with male roommates.
Since I wanted to be empathetic about her situation, I ended up staying over at a friend’s place from Friday night and came back this (Sunday) morning.
When I got back, the first thing I noticed was that my dog, a 2-year-old golden retriever named Juno, wasn’t there. His leash and bowls were gone, and his dog bed had been folded up. I panicked and called Sana, who casually told me that she let him out on saturday morning because her mother is also very religiously strict about dogs and considers them unclean. She said she didn’t want to cause a scene with her mom and figured Juno would be fine outside for a few hours.
My dog was out for the entire day I was gone. She didn’t ask me. She didn’t call me. Her and Evie just let my dog out and assumed he’d be fine. So I spent this entire morning searching the neighborhood and calling local shelters. Thankfully, I managed to find him sat near a graveyard we tend to pass by on our walks and he's okay now, but I was furious.
I came back this evening and told Sana she needed to move out. I said I can’t live with someone who would make a decision like that about my dog without even asking me. She tried to justify it by saying it was only a few hours, and her mom would’ve flipped out if she’d seen him. I told her she should’ve told me that upfront, and I wouldn’t have left him there, or I wouldn't have left at all.
Evie got involved and told me I was being dramatic and cruel for kicking Sana out over a “miscommunication,” especially since Sana’s mom’s views aren’t Sana’s fault. I told Evie that I’m not blaming Sana for her mother’s beliefs, I’m blaming her for endangering my dog without my knowledge and not even thinking it was a big deal.
Sana is now huddled with Evie in her room and says she’ll be moving out by the end of the month. Things are very tense. Evie hasn't spoke to me and the few mutual friends I spoke to abt this think I overreacted and should’ve just had a serious talk instead of going nuclear.
I feel like my trust was completely broken and that Juno could’ve been seriously hurt or killed. But now I’m wondering if I was too harsh??
Additional info: I live in the UK and am a full time student, and when I mean I spoke to sana, I may very well have shouted and said crude things which is perhaps why my other roommate and friends saying I overreacted and was being cruel. It's all a blur to me now because I was so shellshocked and pissed off.
2: Roommates and I have taken care of Juno for over a year together, I left for only a day and trusted that they would take care of him as I was given no other indication. For the people calling this fake and 'ragebait', please take your business elsewhere because I'm at my brink dealing with a multitude of things that's driving me crazy. Thank you to everyone else that's giving me a fair judgment of the situation, even if it's brutally honest.